'Holden Caulfield is part of an esteemed class of literary characters: troubled outsiders. Or, more specifically, troubled outsiders who suck. He also isn’t real, a detail that both sides of the argument seemed to forget.' isle_mcelroy writes
Illustration: Publisher Last week, a debate erupted on Twitter over J. D. Salinger’s 1951 novel, The Catcher in the Rye. A person posted a video on Twitter calling Holden Caulfield a first-generation incel and proto–school shooter; defenders of Caulfield claimed he was a grieving abuse victim — a teenager! — who deserved our utmost sympathy. One viral tweet insisted, “Hating Holden Caulfield means you lack empathy, reading comprehension, or both.
I loved The Catcher in the Rye as a teenager and couldn’t get into it as an adult. I don’t hate Holden, though I don’t ever want to hang out with him. He’s part of an esteemed class of literary characters: troubled outsiders. Or, more specifically, troubled outsiders who suck. He also isn’t real, a detail that both sides of the argument seemed to forget. Since he isn’t real, there’s nothing wrong with hating the guy. Nothing wrong with loving him, either.
The notion that readers ought to empathize with Holden, and that the failure to do so is indicative of a moral failing, is part of an ongoing trend in contemporary literature claiming that fiction can teach readers how to be more empathetic. The research started appearing about a decade ago, first in major newspapers and more recently as clickbaity life hacks: If you’re a bad person, reading literary novels might teach you the value of kindness.
Fiction isn’t meant to make readers better people. It is meant to convey feeling — awe, joy, love, beauty, and, yes, even empathy. Fictional characters, though they inspire intense feelings, are only ever collections of traits. Holden has shades of an incel, shades of a trauma victim, shades of a school shooter, shades of a grieving teenager. However, he isn’t a human; he’s a mirror held up to help readers process how they feel about real people who harbor similar traits.
As a reader, I routinely hate characters who have plenty in common with friends who remain in my life. I have forgiven loved ones for committing the same harms that have rendered many characters villains. This isn’t a contradiction. My relationships to fictional people are not shaped by my relationships to real people, because — and I feel embarrassed having to say this again — real people are real, whereas fictional characters aren’t.
Argentina Últimas Noticias, Argentina Titulares
Similar News:También puedes leer noticias similares a ésta que hemos recopilado de otras fuentes de noticias.
That raggedy guy in The Lord of The Rings: The Rings of Power teasers? Gandalf.Putting Gandalf in The Lord of The Rings: The Rings of Power isn’t canon, but it’s still the right move.
Leer más »
Biden Plan Will Forgive Thousands in Student Loans for Many Borrowers. Here's What to KnowMillions who owe money in federal student loans will have those debts forgiven under a plan announced by President Biden. Here's what to know about the plan.
Leer más »
Two months after the Dobbs ruling, new abortion bans are taking holdA cascade of new abortion 'trigger bans' are taking hold across the country in the aftermath of Roe v. Wade being overturned. Meanwhile, abortion rights groups have been arguing that many state constitutions offer protections for abortion rights.
Leer más »
What you need to know about recycling right in OaklandAre you recycling the right way? Experts share some tips and tricks and explain why it's important to do so.
Leer más »
Crypto Fanatics and Their Love for Real EstateDespite the recent downfall of cryptocurrency, there is a rising trend amongst 'crypto bros' to invest in real assets — specifically, real estate.
Leer más »