In retrospect, it was inevitable that this particular judge would come for contraception. MsReads via voxdotcom
But Kacsmaryk isn’t like most other judges. In his brief time on the bench — Trump appointed Kacsmaryk in 2019 — he has shown an extraordinary willingness toThis behavior is enabled, moreover, by the procedural rules that frequently enable federal plaintiffs in Texas to choose which judge will hear their case — 95 percent of civil cases filed in Amarillo, Texas’s federal courthouse are.
Kacsmaryk’s decision is riddled with legal errors, some of them obvious enough to be spotted by a first-year law student. And it contradicts aamong federal courts that parents do not have a constitutional right to target government programs providing contraceptive care. So there’s a reasonable chance that Kacsmaryk will be reversed on appeal, even in a federal judiciary dominated by Republican appointees.
Nevertheless, Kacsmaryk’s opinion reveals that there are powerful elements within the judiciary who are eager to limit access to contraception. And even if Kacsmaryk’s opinion is eventually rejected by a higher court, he could potentially send the Title X program into turmoil for months.Kacsmaryk’s opinion makes a number of legal errors, some of them egregious.
The Constitution, for example, does not permit litigants to file federal lawsuits challenging a government program unless they’ve been injured in some way by that program — a requirement known as “.” But Alexander Deanda, the father in this case seeking to stop Title X-funded programs from offering contraception to minors, does not claim that he has ever sought Title X-funded care. He does not allege that his daughters have ever sought Title X-funded care.
, the plaintiff in a federal lawsuit must show that they’ve been injured in a manner that is “actual or imminent” and not “conjectural” or “hypothetical.” But Deanda has offered nothing more than conjecture that, if Title X continues to operate as it has for decades, one of his daughters might, at some point in the future, obtain contraception. Kacsmaryk nevertheless allowed his suit to proceed.
Argentina Últimas Noticias, Argentina Titulares
Similar News:También puedes leer noticias similares a ésta que hemos recopilado de otras fuentes de noticias.
Video: Ex-Trump White House lawyer makes prediction about a criminal referral for Trump | CNN PoliticsFormer Trump White House lawyer Ty Cobb tells CNN's ErinBurnett if he believes the January 6th House select committee will issue a criminal referral for former President Donald Trump. Watch here:
Leer más »
Ex-Trump Attorney Has No Doubt Trump Will Be Criminally Referred For Jan. 6 RiotLawyer Ty Cobb has become a fierce critic of his former boss since leaving the White House in 2018.
Leer más »
Analysis | Who convinced Donald Trump that Trump NFTs were a good idea?Who convinced Donald Trump that Trump NFTs were a good idea? They are not.
Leer más »
Opinion | Republicans Sick of Trump Have a Major Problem: The Trump Base'The GOP continues to rot as a political party, as a governing institution, and as a moral entity.'
Leer más »
US judge temporarily halts Biden bid to end Trump-era border policyA federal judge on Thursday temporarily blocked the Biden administration from ending a Trump-era policy requiring asylum-seekers to wait in Mexico for hearings in U.S. immigration court.
Leer más »
Steve Bannon facing same judge who presided over Trump Organization trialBannon accused the district attorney of a politics-driven prosecution; the judge barred the Trump Organization from making that argument.
Leer más »